Another Wave Of Selling Pushed Energy Futures To Fresh Multi-Month Lows On Tuesday

The search for a bottom continues after another wave of selling pushed energy futures to fresh multi-month lows on Tuesday. While most of the futures complex remains on the edge of a technical breakdown, we still haven’t seen the snowball effect of selling that signals the bulls (or more likely their trading algorithms) have finally thrown in the towel.

The most important technical test of the day comes from the RBOB futures contract that managed a modest bounce off of its 200-day moving average Tuesday, and could make a case for a recovery rally if it’s able to sustain a move higher from here. If that layer of support breaks however, there’s not much on the charts to prevent another 20 cents of losses.

We’re seeing a bit of the opposite reaction this morning to the May CPI report that came in just below expectations than we did yesterday when the PPI report showed inflation was still running hot. Both refined products added a penny in the first few minutes following the report, tagging along with a bounce in US equity futures. The annual inflation rate from the CPI came in at 3.4%, which is still well above the FED’s target of 2%, but the monthly rate of .3% was slightly lower than many estimates around .4%. Both the PPI and CPI reports showed the spring rally in fuel prices leading the tick up in inflation, which give us good reason to believe we’ll see lower numbers in June now that both gasoline and diesel futures have dropped 40 cents from their April highs.

ULSD futures hit their lowest level since July 5th of last year, which was just before the contract rallied more than $1/gallon in the next two months. Physical traders are also acting bearish on diesel contracts with more heavy selling in the LA and Group 3 markets which dropped to 14 cent discounts to futures Tuesday, but were left in the dust by Chicago values that collapsed to a 30 cent discount.

The latest crash in Chicago diesel basis combined with futures trading near a 10 month low pushed cash prices to the lowest level we’ve seen since December 2021, offering a seasonally unusual opportunity for those that are still waiting to lock in their fuel price for the next year.

The diesel overhang is also witnessed in the ongoing collapse in California LCFS credit values which reached an 8 year low Tuesday at $45/MT yesterday, down from $140/MT just over 2 years ago. The drop in LCFS values combined with last year’s collapse in RINs and the upcoming change to the blender’s tax credit has already caused the closure of a few biodiesel plants, a re-conversion of a refinery back to traditional fuels, and then Tuesday the world’s largest RD producer issued a profit warning due to a continued decrease in both diesel prices, and the subsidies for renewables. For those that lived through the early days of the ethanol industry that included multiple cycles of bankruptcies and frequent regulation changes wreaking havoc, this cycle on the diesel side of the barrel feels oddly similar.

The IEA continues to bang a bearish drum to try and counteract OPEC’s bullishness in their monthly reports, citing weak demand in Europe as a driver of OECD nations moving into fuel consumption contraction in the first quarter of 2024. The tax-payer funded agency also acknowledged the drop in refinery margins in April as the distillate glut continues across much of the world, while also noting that refinery run rates are set to increase further in the back half of the year. The report also noted that even if OPEC & Friends (now Rebranded as DoC) maintain their output cuts through 2025, growth in output from the US, Guyana, Canada and Brazil will be enough to keep world supply outpacing demand.

RIN prices got a quick bounce this week after a Federal Court denied a refinery suit against the EPA’s RFS rules for 2020-2022, but already gave back those gains yesterday, with D4 and D6 values holding around the $.45/RIN mark, down slightly from this time last year when they were worth about $1.50.

Click here to download a PDF of today's TACenergy Market Talk.